Was I Robbed of a Bestseller?

UnlikelyLast week, I was battling (and losing) jet lag, the requisite wound for international summer travel. What saved me was Gone Girl by Gillian Flynn. In sheets damp with sweat -we came back to a broken air conditioner – I turned pages until the wee hours of the morning. My perspiration could have been attributed to the plot which was full of twists and turns.

What resonated with me, however, more than the dramatic peaks and valleys of the thriller itself, was the structure. A husband and wife, each telling their version of their love story gone wrong, in alternating chapters.

In 2006 I set out to write a book about the decay of a relationship, with alternating voices and chapters, of a boyfriend/girlfriend. The editor I engaged to work on this – my very first project – told me the structure wouldn’t work. I don’t remember the exact words but I do know that project is now in the 15 iteration and has a singular protagonist.

I’m not angry, honest I’m not. Only puzzled. Should I have stuck with my original idea? Could I have made those voices – characters who showed up during a writing workshop in the summer of 2006 – do my will, even if the editor didn’t believe in them?

I was reminded of this nagging feeling I had given up something when I read One Day by David Nicholls for much the same reason as Gone Girl. Boy and girl. Story of meeting, unmeeting, told in the past, then future, then present.

I don’t know if I didn’t have the confidence to tell that type of story. Or if it is better in the hands of experienced writers like Nicholls and Flynn, both of whose books went on to be bestsellers with movie adaptations (Flynn’s is forth coming).

I do know that over 15 books later, edited, fiction and non-fiction, I won’t make the same mistake again. If I have an idea, I will stick to it and give my characters a chance to make their debut in the world.

I have learned a tremendous amount working and reworking that manuscript into the soon to be released book now know as An Unlikely Goddess. I’ve stopped counting the number of revisions; we are somewhere around version 20 and I spent a few hours on Saturday tending to over 200 comments. When the book comes out it will be the culmination of nearly two years in self publishing and over ten years in writing, rewriting, and creating on my journey to becoming a full time writer.

What about you? Have you been given good or bad writing advice?


Enhanced by Zemanta

Posts Tagged with…

Reader Comments

  1. Ryan Biddulph

    Trust your intuition if it speaks to you Mohana and ignore EVERYbody lol! If the small, still voice tells you to do something, do it. Experts, or publishers, or heck anybody, will advise you to do other things, that you are making mistakes. Be open to feedback but never stray from what your intuition tells you.

    I learned this from my writing, business-building, heck everything in life lol! People can provide valued feedback but only if their take vibes with your intuition.

    Thanks for sharing!


  2. Ben Lane Hodson

    It seems like unpublished new authors are required to take less chances with their first work. It’s almost like you have to have a few books under your belt before they “let you” break the rules.

    Write what you love. Innovate. Push the boundaries.

  3. Candace Johnson

    A perfect example of why self-publishing is such a breath of fresh air in the world of publishing! When I work with an author on a manuscript that pushes the envelope (like yours did), I remind him or her that my opinion is only one person’s opinion, and I suggest he or she gather many other opinions from beta readers and other sources, especially when I’m suggesting a major change such as rewriting a POV.

    Six years ago, the editor who told you the way you wanted to tell your story wouldn’t work was probably speaking from the experience of what worked for that particular publisher; much has changed since then. Congratulations on finally bringing that work to the world!

Write a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *